Tuesday, April 19, 2016

Asia's Rich Urged to Buy Dollars as Singapore Fuels Easing Bets



(Bloomberg) -- Money managers for Asia’s wealthy families are telling clients to buy U.S. dollars as a rally this year in regional currencies begins to sputter.

Credit Suisse Group AG is advising its private-banking clients to bet the greenback will gain versus a basket of peers that includes the South Korean won, Taiwan dollar, Thai baht and Philippine peso. UBS Group AG said investors should buy the currency against the Singapore dollar and yen. Stamford Management Pte, which oversees about $250 million for Asia’s rich, urged clients to buy the U.S. dollar each time it falls below S$1.35.

The Monetary Authority of Singapore’s unexpected easing on April 14 has fueled speculation that other policy makers, concerned about a worsening global economic outlook, will follow suit. A gauge of 10 Asian currencies excluding the yen has fallen 0.2 percent this month. The Bloomberg-JPMorgan Asia Dollar Index climbed 1.9 percent in the first three months of the year, the first gain in seven quarters, as traders adjusted bets on the timing of U.S. interest-rate increases.

“We see good opportunity now to hedge against U.S. dollar strength after the strong rally in Asian currencies in the first quarter,” said Koon How Heng, senior foreign-exchange strategist at Credit Suisse’s private banking and wealth management unit in Singapore. “There are risks that other Asian central banks may follow up with some more easing in the second half if their respective growth outlooks deteriorate further.”

The prospect of renewed weakness in the Chinese yuan and two interest rate increases by the Federal Reserve in the second half of the year will boost the greenback, Heng said.

Singapore’s central bank said last week it would seek a policy of zero appreciation against an undisclosed basket of currencies, returning to a neutral stance it adopted in the global financial crisis in 2008. It cited “a less favorable external environment” in its policy statement, two days after the International Monetary Fund warned of the risk of negative shocks to the global economy.

Regional Easing

Policy makers in New Zealand, South Korea and Taiwan will probably cut interest rates in the coming months to revive growth, said Mansoor Mohi-uddin, a strategist at Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc in Singapore. The Bank of Japan is set to increase asset purchases and lower the deposit rate further when it sets policy on April 28, he said.

“The MAS move raises the risk other central banks become more willing to ease policy as Singapore’s economy is seen as a bellwether for Asia,” he said.

The U.S. dollar will advance to S$1.42 by the first quarter of 2017 and 122 yen in 12 months, said Kelvin Tay, regional chief investment officer at UBS’s wealth management business in Singapore. The greenback bought S$1.3517 and 108.87 yen at 6:15 a.m. in Singapore Tuesday.

“The rally in Asian currencies was overdone,” Tay said. “It wasn’t on the back of really strong fundamentals coming through.”

The greenback is set to gain to S$1.40 versus the Singapore dollar in the next few months, said Jason Wang, chief executive officer of Stamford Management. He had advised clients to buy the U.S. currency when it declined toward a nine-month low of S$1.3415 in March, saying that it was unlikely to fall below S$1.35 again this year.

“Dollar strength will continue to prevail for the next few months, which would be negative for emerging-market currencies,” Wang said. “I don’t expect any of the Southeast Asian currencies to diverge or outperform the dollar.” 



Negative Interest Rates: Keynes Revisited

Negative interest rate policies have started to unnerve investors, even though Sweden, Denmark, the eurozone and Switzerland have all had negative policy rates for over a year. 




This year, amid global growth jitters, investors have started to worry about whether negative deposit rates undermine the profitability of the banking sector. Japanese banking stocks have underperformed global peers by 17% since the Bank of Japan cut the deposit rate to -10 basis points on 29 January. Even more disconcerting were sharp spikes in bank funding markets, which led some commentators to question whether this could threaten their solvency. While these spikes were short-lived, many investors are wondering if cuts deeper into negative territory would see them return. 

We believe that negative policy rates are not as bad for commercial banks as most people think, and that markets have overreacted. Foremost, negative rates on deposits with the Swedish, Danish, Japanese and eurozone central banks apply only to new reserves. So it is far more important to focus on the average interest rate applied to the whole stock of reserves. 

In Switzerland and the eurozone, the mandatory reserves that regulators require commercial banks to hold with the central bank are not subject to negative rates. In Sweden and Denmark, a more complex system of refinancing provisions effectively negates the negative rate on mandatory reserves too. 

Of course, additional asset purchase programmes by the ECB and the BoJ are likely to raise the excess amount of money banks hold on reserve above the minimum requirement threshold, and this will push up that average rate of interest. However, the positive contribution to bank earnings generated by capital gains on holdings of government bonds will provide an offsetting force. Capital Economics also calculates that the annual cost of negative deposit rates to the Swiss banking sector is equivalent to 0.04% of bank assets, and just 0.01% in the eurozone, Sweden and Denmark. Given that European net interest income is circa 1-1.5% of bank assets, the cost is not that great. 

Central bank deposit rates: Negative rates are nothing new



Fundamentally, banks do not earn their profits from the money they hold on deposit – they make their money from borrowing short and lending long. In this regard, negative deposit rates are a more attractive prospect than extending QE to corporate bonds and asset-backed securities; smashing down yields here makes it even more difficult for banks to eke out a net interest margin. 

So will negative interest rates come up with the goods? We are, of course, in uncharted waters. Although not explicit, most readers of John Maynard Keynes’ General Theory infer the premise, ‘[given] that nominal interest rates cannot be negative’. Nobody has really challenged that theory for 80 years! The experience so far suggests that changes to modestly negative rates are passed through to money market rates. Moreover, there is anecdotal evidence that banks are seeking to avoid negative rates in their sovereign bond holdings by lending to riskier counterparties. 

Yet the evidence is mixed when it comes to lending rates into the real economy. Banks have been reluctant to pass on negative deposit rates to retail depositors for fear of substantial deposit withdrawals. It is much easier for a retail depositor to store their relatively small sums of cash in a small cupboard under the stairs, than for corporate depositors, who would need to rent specialist vault space! This reluctance may have limited the extent to which banks were willing to convert lower policy rates into lower mortgage rates, for example, eager as they were to avoid further squeezing retail net interest margins. In particular, Swiss banks have actually raised the lending rate on mortgages since policy rates turned negative, while mortgage rates in Sweden and Denmark have remained more or less unchanged. 

Overall, we think interest rate changes have a diminishing effect on money creation the more negative they become. However, there are few theoretical reasons to refute that a constructive relationship will remain intact, even though there is profound uncertainty about the behaviour of borrowers and savers if interest rates were to remain significantly negative for a prolonged period of time. 

The main limitation is the existence of hard cash. At some point it will become cost-effective to store deposits outside of a bank, and the longer negative interest rates are in place, the more competition will erode those costs. Even here there are plenty of interesting things that policymakers could do: large-value notes could be eliminated, pushing up the vault space required; bank notes could be taxed, making currency non-redeemable for deposits in banks; or cash could be eliminated entirely. However, we are a long way from the deeply negative rates at which these ‘wonk-tastic’ ideas might become a reality. 

We are sanguine on the impact negative rates will have on bank profitability, and tentatively optimistic on the potential for negative interest rates to help the economy – particularly when considered alongside other forms of stimulus. However, European banks are far from fixed. European bank loans did not start declining until a full four years after their US peers, so substantial losses still need to be crystalised by European banks. And yet, few of these banks have managed to make a return that covers their cost of capital over the last five years. 

As a result, we expect a series of mini-existential crises, triggered by rate cuts or otherwise, to continue to drive bank stock price volatility, for which investors are unlikely to be sufficiently compensated. - portfolio-advisers


Friday, April 15, 2016

The Investment Habits of the Wealthy Investor



The wealthy have always worn a mantle of mystery: their gated communities, private memberships, exclusive clubs and the like emphasizing this “otherness.” Their investment management activities are no different; most high-net-worth investors employ a professional advisor to stand between them and those who clamor to serve them.

Yet the wealthy share many of the same investment goals and objectives as institutions. They want returns balanced by reasonable risk, some form of income, long-range planning that fits their current and future anticipated needs, and diversification among assets. Wealthy investors are as suited for alternative asset allocations as the foundations, endowments, and institutions that have been actively investing in them for decades. But the strategies most successful in accessing the wealthy community require a different set of tactics. Data and analysis take a backseat to interaction and education when breaking through to the wealthy audience.

FOLLOW THE MONEY

A survey encompassed a cross section of 640 high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth adults with at least $3 million in investable assets, equally divided among those who have between $3 million and $5 million, $5 million and $10 million, and $10 million or more.


  • First, 66% use some type of professional financial advisor such as a private banker, wealth manager, broker or financial planner, with about 25% relying on a private banker or wealth manager as their primary advisor.
  • Second, among the two-thirds of the wealthy using a financial advisor, they are also notably more likely to be using non-traditional investments in their portfolios.
  • Third, almost two-thirds of high-net-worth investors (62%) have 10% or more of their portfolio in cash, indicating continued uncertainty about market risk. Slightly more than a third (36%) said they would be willing to take on higher risk to achieve higher returns.

BREAK ON THROUGH TO THE OTHER SIDE

So, how should alternatives managers get the ball rolling with these elusive but potential investors? Start with what is important to them. The high net worth community has been very clear on several fundamental values they consider core: relationships, trust, expertise, and guidance. Investment managers need to show that they share these core values before they can hope to persuade these investors to consider their offerings. Tactically, there are several avenues managers can explore in this effort.


  • Begin by building a relationship with their advisors. Most managers hold fast to the notion that, if they could only get an opportunity to sit down in front of an investor, they can sell them on their conviction and ability to deliver great results. What these managers fail to understand is that these high net worth investors are not the primary individuals they should pursue. As the survey findings reflect, most of these investors rely on the guidance of financial advisors to drive their investment activities. Managers who try to go directly to the investor often find themselves blocked or ignored, not because they are unsuitable, but because this method is outside the introductory channel preferred by most wealthy investors.

Time spent persuading advisors of the unique and attractive elements of their alternative offering will be time well spent in gaining introductions to the right types of high-net-worth investors who could potentially invest with them. This advisor outreach can be done in a number of ways: identification and individual contact, attendance at industry organizations and events where these advisors congregate, and referrals to appropriate advisors through professional networking.


  • Demonstrate integrity to earn their trust. Managers must show a history of consistent, ethical, and reliable decision-making and execution to impress upon advisors and high net worth investors that they are worthy of exploration. Prior to beginning the relationship-building process, managers should take a personal inventory and get clear on articulating and demonstrating examples of this holistic behavior. They might assemble a short list of references that support this integrity looking back through their personal and professional lives. This might include prior work, volunteer activities, personal interests and affiliations, and others.

This reflection may be somewhat new to managers recently separating from purely institutional investment management roles, but is critical in forging new relationships within the advisor and high net worth communities.


  • Explain your process and abilities through storytelling and case studies. The power of communicating through examples is an underappreciated investment tactic in alternatives. Relying on performance history, peer rankings, and data analysis doesn’t resonate as powerfully as insightful interaction with the wealthy audience. Crafting two or three comprehensive investment examples can bring this less-appreciated and often misunderstood strategy into focus for advisors and investors, while helping them relate to their own portfolio objectives.

As a general guideline, managers might articulate why a particular investment target was attractive to them for their strategy approach, what was the market environment surrounding this target at the time of initiation, what occurred during the holding that supported or detracted from its position, and what outcome resulted from the exit of the position for the manager’s portfolio. A flow such as this illustrates in tangible form market opportunity, strategy approach and execution, and the value-add of the alternative investment differentiated from general market performance. This outline works regardless of specific strategy, and is more memorable than a dry recitation of performance data to the majority of high net worth investors seeking to be educated about alternative investments.


  • Educate them about the advantages of alternatives. Besides creating these strategy-specific case studies, managers can join the broader discussion of education by creating various forms of communication about the advantages of alternatives. While the institutional investment community is well-stocked by analysts, consultants, and investment management professionals with research, white papers, surveys, and regular reports on the discipline of alternative investing for portfolio allocation, there is a paucity of such material tailored for high-net-worth investors.

Most of the material currently available superficially discusses differentiation and non correlation in portfolio allocation. Adding the unique voices and expertise of alternative managers who build such products is much needed and desired by the advisors and investors who will ultimately select offerings from these managers. These managers can:


  • lend their commentary as industry experts to financial channels read by advisors and investors,
  • create their own educational newsletters or blogs highlighting a market perspective and outlook,
  • offer themselves to alternative conferences or events as speakers or moderators.

Persuasion is the key to all these tactics. Managers who embrace both education and implementation of strategy will make greater inroads with the hard-to-crack advisor and high net worth community that is open to learn from them. - all about alpha


Thursday, April 14, 2016

Currency Traders Punish Singapore Dollar


SINGAPORE, 14 April 2016: 

Singapore’s dollar was on track for its worst day in more than eight months today, leading losses among emerging Asian currencies, after the city state’s central bank unexpectedly eased its exchange-rate based monetary policy.
Regional currencies slumped on broad strength in the US dollar. The yuan slid as China’s central bank set its daily guidance rate at the softest level in April so far, reflecting the greenback’s gain.

The Monetary Authority of Singapore said it will set the rate of appreciation of the Singapore dollar’s nominal effective exchange rate (NEER) policy band at 0%, starting today, shifting from its previous policy stance of a “modest and gradual” appreciation of the Singapore dollar.

The MAS last shifted from “modest and gradual” appreciation to a 0% appreciation stance in October 2008.

The Singapore dollar dropped 1% to 1.3650 versus the greenback, its weakest since March 29. If maintained, the daily depreciation would mark the biggest slide since Aug 11, according to Thomson Reuters data.

Some hedge funds dumped the city-state’s unit after the  unexpected decision.
“The MAS surprised markets by moving to a zero appreciation slope,” analysts for Nomura said in a research note.

“We see some further risk of depreciation in the near term, not so much from this mild shift in policy (from +0.5% to 0% annualised appreciation), but from the risk that expectations of further easing this year could increase.”

The Singapore dollar has been the third-best performing emerging Asian currency so far this year, partially amid expectations that the central bank would keep the policy unchanged this week.

Its weakness was exacerbated as the US dollar rose broadly, posting its biggest one-day gain in more than a month against a basket of six major currencies.
“The impact we think will likely be transient. However, because of the slightly more supported broad USD in the last 36 hours, the USD/SGD may be incrementally more buoyant in the short term,” said Emmanuel Ng, a foreign exchange strategist with OCBC Bank in Singapore.

Related -

  1. Singapore ‘pegs’ currency value, says economic growth slowing
  2. Ringgit stronger vs Singapore dollar as Singapore central bank curbs currency appreciation
  3. MAS surprise easing sends Singapore dollar reeling


Wednesday, April 13, 2016

Offshore Funds: Where is the Money and Is It Safe?


As the Panama Papers leak shines a light on offshore funds available in the UK, we examine the tax issues and what protections are offered.

The Panama Papers have given a glimpse into the secretive world of offshore funds used by wealthy individuals – including the prime minister’s father – to stash cash in tax havens but are they inherently dodgy or a legitimate way to invest?

An unprecedented leak of 11.5 million documents from law firm Mossack Fonseca, which is based in Panama, one of the world’s largest tax havens, has shed light on some of the labyrinthine structures the wealthy put in place to hide their money and avoid tax.

Within the documents, it was revealed 12 national leaders – among a total of 143 politicians and their families – have been funnelling cash into offshore tax havens, including a $2 billion trail that leads back to Russian president Vladimir Putin.

The UK’s own prime minister David Cameron has also been implicated as his father, Ian Cameron, was a client of the law firm and in the early 1980s set up a multi-million pound investment fund in the Bahamas called Blairmore Holdings, named after the family’s ancestral home in Scotland.

The fund managed millions on behalf of families including restaurant owner J Sheekey and private bank Leopold Joseph. However, in 30 years it has never paid any tax in the UK.

The prime minister has tried to distance himself from the furore over his father’s, and by implication his, tax affairs. A spokesman for 10 Downing Street said: ‘There are no offshore funds/ trusts which the prime minster, Mrs Cameron or their children will benefit from in the future.’

However, Cameron later admitted he previously held shares in Blairmore, selling them for £31,500 shortly before he became prime minister.

Although there is nothing illegal about the methods used by those named in the Panama Papers, aggressive tax avoidance has been heavily criticised by the Conservative government and it has made efforts to be seen as the party clamping down on wealthy tax evaders.

This included the introduction of a register of beneficial ownership, which is trying to crack the problem of offshore shell companies being used to avoid tax. By understanding who is the recipient of benefits from shell companies, governments can then tax the gains appropriately.

An Organisation for the Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) agreement to share information will also help identify tax dodgers who have squirrelled their money offshore.

The Panama revelations show that information sharing is needed more than ever and again asks the question of whether pushing money offshore can ever be a truly legitimate way for UK residents to invest and tax plan.

Offshore offers

UK investors have access to over 4,000 offshore funds that have a combined value of £1.9 trillion, with the majority of the funds domiciled (or set up in) Luxembourg or Dublin, proving that it is a lucrative stream of business for asset management companies.

Jorge Morley-Smith, director of business support at the Investment Association, said there were ‘any number of reasons a fund would domicile offshore’ that did not include tax avoidance.

'Mostly it is to do with who the fund is being marketed to and how the fund is going to be run,’ he said.

Morley-Smith said regulatory rules also determined where investment managers liked to domicile funds, often moving offshore to get round investment regulation they believed would be a constraint.

‘Over the last 20 years people set up hedge funds and do not want to be constrained. The reason why they use the Cayman Islands is because they do not have the same restrictions on investment…there is more flexibility,’ he said.

It is not just regulation that fuels the creation of offshore funds, according to John Christensen, executive director of the Tax Justice Network.

He said offshore funds were set up due to a ‘combination’ of regulation, tax and secrecy.

‘Fund managers themselves are earning a small fortune so they like to be in a tax-free environment,’ he said. ‘The regulatory environment [in some offshore jurisdictions] is permissive by any standards and the supervisory environment is weak to non-existent – the law in the statue books may look fantastic but without supervision the [laws] are just bits of paper.’

He said people channelling money into offshore funds were ‘those holding cash offshore and who do not want it to be onshore and often they are operating offshore companies’, adding that offshore funds were ‘where money meets money on the street and does business’.

Christensen said there was no offshore jurisdiction that was more credible than another, as was evidenced by 2014's 'Lux Leaks' scandal, which implicated Luxembourg as the centre of tax avoidance deals orchestrated by the big four accounting firms.

Christensen said British jurisdictions such as the Isle of Man, Jersey and Guernsey, could not be seen as more legitimate than other tax havens as the rules were ‘just window dressing’.

‘It all depends on the politicians – if you have politicians who are not captive to the financial services industry and law firms then you have strong regulation and a strong regulator but if you have a captive state – which Panama and places like British Virgin Islands are – then you have a combination of weak politicians and a weak regulator and weak supervision.’

Should you go offshore?

The lax regulation and supervisory environments offered by offshore jurisdictions may be attractive to fund management companies who can use them to their advantage but there are question marks over the benefits they provide for individuals.

Morley-Smith said ‘it entirely depends on the investor’ if they feel comfortable investing offshore or not but said UK-based investors would face the same tax consequences whichever jurisdiction they picked.

‘There are the same [personal] tax consequences of investing in offshore funds [in whatever jurisdiction],’ he said.

‘The tax rules are designed so the choice of jurisdiction or vehicle does not matter. If you invest in an offshore fund you will have a requirement to fill in a certain box on a tax return [in the UK], it does not matter if the fund is in the Cayman Islands or Luxembourg.’

And investors shouldn’t try and skirt the law by failing to fill in offshore income and gains on their UK tax return as the OECD information-sharing agreement ensures they will be found out.

‘There is the agreement that the government has entered into to share information. The rules state that if you have investments in an offshore fund or have an offshore bank account the information will passed between the governments so a Cayman Islands fund will report to HM Revenue & Customs…It will be effective from this year and will make it harder to hide money [offshore]. Panama had not signed up but all countries where people typically have funds have signed up,’ he said.

Investors pulled offshore may not be doing so to avoid tax, merely because they are a fan of the investment on offer, however they should realise that investing offshore may leave them out of pocket thanks to the lack of compensation schemes operating in offshore jurisdictions.

If an investor puts money into an offshore fund, which subsequently collapses due to mis-management (there is no compensation for funds that perform badly) there will be little to no protection on offer. If a UK-based company or adviser encouraged an investor into a fund, then it may be possible to receive compensation from the UK Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS), which pays out on losses up to a maximum of £50,000. 

Offshore Centers Around the World

1. Isle of Man

  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 13
  • Collective value of the funds: £537 million 
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: 100% of the first £30,000, 90% up to the next £20,000 to a total of £48,000

2. Luxembourg
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 2,775
  • Collective value of the funds: £1.2 trillion 
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: No compensation scheme that covers Ucits open-ended funds
3. Ireland
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 1,378
  • Collective value of the funds: £637 billion
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: If a Ucits open-ended fund domiciled in Ireland (typically Dublin) collapses there is no recourse from the compensation scheme. However an investor can claim if the fund has been mis-sold by an Irish adviser. The scheme pays out up to 90% of the total claim up to a limit of €20,000.
4. Guernsey
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 21
  • Collective value of the funds: £1.2 billion 
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: The Collective Investment Scheme Rules 1988 provide compensation up to 90% of the first £50,000 and 30% of the balance up to £100,000 – a maximum total of £60,000. The compensation scheme pays out an absolute total of £5 million a year.
5. Jersey
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 20
  • Collective value of the funds: £7 billion 
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: No compensation scheme that covers Ucits open-ended funds
6. Bermuda
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 1 
  • Collective value of the funds: unknown
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: No compensation scheme
7. The Bahamas
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 1
  • Collective value of the funds: unknown 
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: No compensation scheme
8. British Virgin Islands
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 2
  • Collective value of the funds: £42 million
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: No compensation scheme
9. Cayman Islands
  • Number of open-ended funds domiciled in the area: 5
  • Collective value of the funds: £841.6 million
  • Information sharing with UK in place: Yes
  • Compensation offered: No compensation scheme
- citywire


Related - 

  1. I feel sorry for David Cameron. The focus on his tax affairs diverts attention from the worst offshore rackets
  2. Cameron admits he profited from father's offshore fund


Tuesday, April 12, 2016

How to Invest Amid a Negative Interest Rate Environment

Japan is one of the countries that has adopted a negative interest rate policy. Photo: Reuters.


The financial market volatility at the beginning of this year was partly due to investors’ concerns that a negative interest rate would be broadly adopted.

Although such a move aims to stimulate economic activity, investors worry about banks’ earnings and solvency ratios and the impact on the confidence of consumers and firms.

A negative interest rate is an unconventional measure. It’s like doing an experiment, and investors can’t know for sure how the policy will affect the market.

In most economies, the yield curves for government bonds become flatter.

It will suppress the willingness of banks to lend. Their net interest margin is likely to narrow, as the lending rate will be reduced while the deposit rate for retail clients remains above zero.

Investors should be clear that a negative interest rate is intended to encourage people to pursue risky economic activity instead of holding cash.

Identifying the long-term investment and economic theme is necessary to guide investors through a situation of low returns and high market volatility.

Uncertainties will come from negative interest rates, energy prices, China’s economic transformation and geopolitical issues, such as Brexit.

Besides accepting credit risk from the fixed-income market, investors can also make use of the risky nature of the stock market and the liquidity risk of alternative investments to realize higher potential return.

Valuation of stocks is at an attractive level now, especially in emerging markets and in Asia.

As for alternative investments, investors may consider private equity investments or hold physical assets.

Investors should focus on the contribution of the return from certain asset classes to the overall portfolio.

For example, in the past 10 years, the compounding effect of stock dividends and the return from reinvestment of the dividends provided over 60 percent of the overall return in Asian stock markets and 40 percent of the return in the Standard & Poor’s 500.

So, in the face of negative interest rates, market volatility will remain at a high level.

A super loose monetary environment will lead to lower expected returns and drive investors to make longer-term investments while taking market, credit and liquidity risks to enhance overall return.

We believe that fixed-income products and stock dividends will make bigger contributions to portfolio returns. 

This article appeared in the Hong Kong Economic Journal on April 11.



Alternative Reality


Key points

  • The investment universe of alternatives is now large and growing.
  • Investment trusts and companies provide an answer to many of the problems of investing in alternatives.
  • In recent years the number of alternative asset-focused investment trusts has increased significantly.
Alternative assets encompass a broad range of investments which offer a different risk and return profile from traditional asset classes.

The investment universe of alternatives is now large and growing. Property, private equity, commodities and hedge funds are examples of alternative asset investments that have existed over the longer term. More recently, renewable energy, infrastructure, loans and reinsurance have all emerged as alternative asset classes. It is likely that the universe will continue to expand, for example, peer-to-peer lending funds have recently emerged as an additional sub-sector.

One of the key benefits of alternative assets is the diversification that they can bring to a portfolio. During 2015 many developed equity markets touched all-time highs while fixed income market yields remained near historic lows. As both equity and fixed income markets have climbed over recent years, partly as a result of accommodative monetary policy from central banks, the correlation between their returns has increased. While investors have enjoyed a sustained period of good returns, the diversification benefit from holding equities and bonds in a balanced portfolio has arguably decreased. If this is the case, assets with low correlations to equity and fixed income markets are now even more important for investors in order to maintain an acceptably diversified portfolio.

There are many reasons why it is difficult for most investors to invest in alternatives either directly or through the investment vehicles that have been used to invest in alternatives in the past. Investment in alternatives often requires long-term investment horizons and it can be costly for investors to seek liquidity in the short term. For example, it is unlikely that individual investors would be able to invest directly into private equity as an asset class. Instead, investors have traditionally obtained exposure via limited partnership structures where a general partner (the manager) invests on their behalf.

Typically limited partnerships would invest over a period of around five years and then take a further five years or so to realise investments and return capital to investors. Investors looking to exit the partnership before the end of the vehicle’s life may have to sell their investment at a significant discount to carrying value in order to obtain liquidity. As the alternatives universe has expanded limited partnership structures have been used by other asset classes such as infrastructure and renewable energy managers. Similarly, direct property investments tend to be long-term in nature due to the significant transaction costs involved. These costs are far in excess of those suffered by investors in traditional asset classes.

A second hurdle hampering the individual investor’s ability to access alternatives is the size of the capital commitment required. Limited partnership structures often have minimum commitment levels and in some cases the manager will charge a higher fee to investors that commit capital below a certain threshold. This is akin to how many hedge funds operate. Hedge funds will often have minimum investment levels and charge different fees to investors who commit different amounts of capital. Investing directly in property requires significant capital due to the nature of the underlying assets and the fact that they cannot be sub-divided.

Complexity provides an additional barrier to investing directly in alternatives. Alternative assets are diverse by nature and, in some instances, are at a relatively early stage of market acceptance. As a result, they are less well researched academically, less well covered by the investment community and are often more difficult to assess than traditional asset classes. In recent years a number of new alternative asset classes have emerged that highlight the complexity that can be involved in investing in alternatives. For example, reinsurance funds invest in contracts that pay premiums for cover against catastrophic events. It is outside of nearly all traditional investors capabilities to model these catastrophic events and requires specialist investment expertise.

Open-ended funds are an alternative way for investors to access some alternatives. A number of direct property open-ended funds exist. The problem with holding property assets and some other illiquid assets in an open-ended fund structure is clear. If an open-ended fund has significant redemptions the fund management team may be unable to liquidate assets to meet these redemptions which can lead to the situation where redemptions are suspended. Thus, a supposedly liquid access to alternatives becomes illiquid, although rare a number of investors in direct open-ended property funds did experience this during 2008 and 2009.

Investment trusts and companies provide an answer to many of the problems of investing in alternatives either directly or via open-ended funds. Investment trusts are closed-ended in structure, the number of shares in issue is static unless the trust decides to undertake a share issuance or buy back.

Investor demand for closed-ended vehicles does vary over time as asset classes and particular funds go in and out of favour. As a result the price of a closed-ended vehicle will usually be different from the net asset value (NAV) of the underlying assets depending on investor perception of their quality, growth potential and yield amongst other things. Some asset classes, such as infrastructure currently trade on average at a significant premium to NAV. Others, such as private equity, commodities and hedge funds, currently trade on average at a discount.

In recent years the number of alternative asset-focused investment trusts has increased significantly. The benefits of the closed-ended structure and increased correlation of traditional asset classes are supporting this growth in the alternative asset universe. - ftadviser